VirtualBox

Opened 6 years ago

Closed 6 years ago

#18286 closed defect (fixed)

DOS-class VMs don't recognize PCnet-FAST III (6.0.0 regression) => fixed in svn

Reported by: Socratis Owned by:
Component: network Version: VirtualBox 6.0.0
Keywords: PCnet-FAST III, DOS guests Cc:
Guest type: other Host type: all

Description

Based on a discussion in the forums (Possible bug: unrecognized PCnet-FAST III network card (in a guest DOS) with VirtualBox 6.0), it seems that there's an issue with the emulation of the above mentioned card.

It has been confirmed by multiple users.

Disclaimer: I have not tried this personally, I'm planning on it...

Attachments (2)

dos-networking.zip (45.2 KB ) - added by andyp1973 6 years ago.
Logs from identical VM guest running under 5.2.22 and 6.0.1
vbox-freedos-pcnet-bug.zip (24.6 KB ) - added by PThorn 6 years ago.
FreeDos 1.2 VM log with manual PCNET driver config and an attempt to run dhcp.exe

Download all attachments as: .zip

Change History (13)

comment:1 by andyp1973, 6 years ago

I have tried this with dev build 6.0.1 r127640 and the problem persists.

-Andy.

by andyp1973, 6 years ago

Attachment: dos-networking.zip added

Logs from identical VM guest running under 5.2.22 and 6.0.1

comment:2 by andyp1973, 6 years ago

Slight clarification...

The 5.2.22 log comes from a Linux host the 6.0.1 from a macOS host but the only difference in setup is the network device being bridged to.

-Andy.

comment:3 by PThorn, 6 years ago

I was able to get the driver to detect the card by adding parameters to the command line:

PCNTPK.COM INT=0x60 IRQ=0x0A IOADDR=0xD020

(took the values from the last screenshot here). With this change the driver correctly prints the MAC address as set in the VM config. However, dhcp.exe fails with timeout errors. So I used wireshark to see if there is any traffic coming out of the VM. Turns out there is: the VM sends DHCP DISCOVER packets and my DHCP server responds with OFFERs. The VM does not seem to receive those DHCP responses though.

Other VMs (Ubuntu, etc.) with the same net config (bridge to en0, the adapter type is different of course) successfully obtain DHCP leases and have network connectivity under the same VirtualBox instance.

VirtualBox 6.0.0 release, macOS 10.14.2.

by PThorn, 6 years ago

Attachment: vbox-freedos-pcnet-bug.zip added

FreeDos 1.2 VM log with manual PCNET driver config and an attempt to run dhcp.exe

comment:4 by michaln, 6 years ago

Summary: DOS-class VMs don't recognize PCnet-FAST III (6.0.0 regression)DOS-class VMs don't recognize PCnet-FAST III (6.0.0 regression) => fixed in svn

Yes, this was a regression in 6.0.0, should be now fixed.

The problem was not so much with DOS VMs as with specific drivers which failed to detect the emulated hardware. The DOS packet drivers were affected, NetWare client and server drivers were affected. DOS NDIS drivers were not affected, and neither were Windows and OS/2 NDIS drivers or Linux drivers.

comment:5 by Socratis, 6 years ago

Can you try the latest test build, r128070 or later?

comment:6 by PThorn, 6 years ago

Build 128072 (macOS) is confirmed working. Thanks for the fix!

comment:7 by andyp1973, 6 years ago

Likewise, I can confirm that this is working using 6.0.1-r128072 (also on a macOS host).

-Andy.

comment:8 by haakondahl, 6 years ago

Any projected date for the release?

comment:9 by Socratis, 6 years ago

@haakondahl
There's never a projected release date for any version. If you're immediately affected, install the latest test build.

in reply to:  9 comment:10 by haakondahl, 6 years ago

Replying to socratis:

@haakondahl
There's never a projected release date for any version. If you're immediately affected, install the latest test build.

Thank you. I'm new to this. I'm leery about modifying UEFI settings -- have worked around using mkisofs and some disk-swapping. Which is part of the DOS experience, so... I shall wait patiently and be grateful.

comment:11 by Michael Thayer, 6 years ago

Resolution: fixed
Status: newclosed
Note: See TracTickets for help on using tickets.

© 2024 Oracle Support Privacy / Do Not Sell My Info Terms of Use Trademark Policy Automated Access Etiquette